Capture-Recapture

On this page

Estimate the size of a population from the tagged fraction of a second sample, state an assumption, and explain what a wrong assumption or an impossible estimate means.

The method

Some animals are caught, tagged and released. Later a second sample is caught, and the tagged animals in it are counted.

Put the tagged numbers on top of both fractions, and the whole sample and the whole population underneath.

Give the number the calculation gives. Do not round it to 1 significant figure because the question says “estimate”.

Worked example 1: An estimate, then an assumption

Ravi wants to work out an estimate for the number of squirrels in a wood.

On Monday he catches 30 squirrels. He puts a tag on each one and releases them.

On Friday he catches 48 squirrels. 8 of these squirrels have a tag.

(a) Work out an estimate for the number of squirrels in the wood.

(b) State one assumption you have made.

  1. (a) Tagged fraction of Friday's sample: \dfrac{8}{48}
  2. Make it equal to the tagged fraction of the wood:\dfrac{8}{48}=\dfrac{30}{N}
  3. N=\dfrac{30\times48}{8}so N=180
  4. Adding and taking away the counts, 30+48-8=70, is a common wrong answer: the method compares fractions.
  5. (b) No squirrels joined or left the wood between Monday and Friday.
  6. Other assumptions the mark schemes accept: no tags came off; none were born and none died; the second sample was random; the tagged squirrels had time to mix with the rest. A sentence about the calculation is not an assumption.

Now try this

Ali wants to work out an estimate for the number of mice in a barn.

On Tuesday he catches 45 mice. He puts a mark on each one and lets them go.

On Thursday he catches 56 mice. 7 of these mice have a mark.

Work out an estimate for the number of mice in the barn.

  1. Marked fraction on Thursday: \dfrac{7}{56}
  2. \dfrac{7}{56}=\dfrac{45}{N}
  3. N=\dfrac{45\times56}{7}so N=360

More like this: practice questions

Worked example 2: Estimating a total from a sample

A box contains 15 red beads and some other beads.

Priya takes a sample of 40 beads at random from the box. 6 of the beads in her sample are red.

Work out an estimate for the total number of beads in the box.

  1. The same method: the red beads play the part of the tagged animals.
  2. \dfrac{6}{40}=\dfrac{15}{N}
  3. N=\dfrac{15\times40}{6}so N=100
  4. 15\times6=90 and 40-6+15=49 are common wrong answers.

Now try this

A jar contains 24 blue marbles and some yellow marbles.

Kim takes 50 marbles from the jar at random. 8 of them are blue.

Work out an estimate for the total number of marbles in the jar.

  1. \dfrac{8}{50}=\dfrac{24}{N}
  2. N=\dfrac{24\times50}{8}so N=150

More like this: practice questions

The one-mark explanations

If an assumption is wrong, say which way the estimate moves. If tags came off, fewer tagged animals turn up in the second sample than should, so the estimate is too big: there are fewer animals than it says. “My answer would be wrong” or “it would change” does not say which way.

If an estimate cannot be right, compare it with a number of animals actually caught. If 60 crabs were caught in one sample, there are at least 60 crabs, so an estimate of 50 cannot be right. Tags coming off, or the sample being too small, does not answer this.

Practice questions